FANDOM


  • Dear Vampire Ra's Al Ghul, I'm writing you because I was searching through the history for Frank Castle/The Punisher's page, and I found that you were the one who added "Frank was enlisted in the marines after 9/11, and was 18, placing Frank's birthdate in 1982.", to the trivia category, and I was wondering what your source(s) for how you know this are. Please let me know if this is true, along with a link to your source(s), or if it is just made up. Thanks.

    Sincerely, 123BC

      Loading editor
    • I was coming to ask as well but I see it's already been asked. Please could you explain these edits:

      Because there is no source for it - there has never been one provided or found - and it's a repeated issue on the page. If it was simply because of Richochet60's edit (in which he also claimed that Frank served with Flash Thompson), then that's understandable, as the information was on the article, seemingly incorrectly, and it's a shame it took so long to be undone. It has led to some repeated erroneous edits by a few other users based on the things placed in the article, and a couple of users keep adding it back.

      However, if you made the edits based on a piece of information you had, could you provide a source? If not, I think we can put this to bed for good as all just stemming from that strange headcanon edit.

        Loading editor
    • I apologize for not responding sooner. I didn't put that information without accuracy. I should've listed a source and for that I'm sorry. As for Castle's YOB, it was mentioned during his trial that he enlisted after the 9/11 attacks. In 2x12, Schoonover mentioned that Castle picked up his first piece at 18.

        Loading editor
    • Vampire Ra's Al Ghul wrote: I apologize for not responding sooner. I didn't put that information without accuracy. I should've listed a source and for that I'm sorry. As for Castle's YOB, it was mentioned during his trial that he enlisted after the 9/11 attacks. In 2x12, Schoonover mentioned that Castle picked up his first piece at 18.

      I rewatched the season recently and never caught a moment when it is said that he enlisted after 9/11. We know he was in the military at age 18 because of what Schoonover said, and he can't have enlisted earlier than 18 as well, so sure, he enlisted at 18, I'm aware of that. I'm willing to be proven wrong here with the 9/11 thing, but I've never seen an actual quote or source about that and have never caught that piece of information when watching the show.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.

Bring Your MCU Movies Together