- "May your neighbours respect you, trouble neglect you, the angels protect you, and heaven accept you."
Murdered by Finn Cooley
In the wake of the Massacre at the Burren Club, which claimed the lives of Nesbitt and several other members of the Kitchen Irish, Seamus led the remaining members in funeral service for their fallen allies in which he recited a short prayer. Their service was interrupted when Finn Cooley arrived, having traveled from Ireland to pay respect to his son who had been killed by the Punisher. Seamus ordered Rory to bring Cooley a drink as they discussed Cooley's grief. However just as Seamus comforted his ally, Cooley snapped and stabbed Seamus in the eye with an icepick, causing him to scream in agony as Cooley plunged the blade deeper into his skull until it reached his brain, killing him.