Nick Fury became suspicious about the real purpose of Project Insight and secretly hired Georges Batroc to hijack the Lemurian Star. Jasper Sitwell was ordered to board the vessel by Victoria Hand, taking him away from assisting in the search for the Clairvoyant.
Captain America was trying to adjust to the present and its politics by moving to Washington, D.C. and listening to Black Widow's suggestions. Unbeknownst to S.H.I.E.L.D., HYDRA had been planting secret double-agents in the organization for decades.
The Lemurian Star was in the Indian Ocean about to send up the last Project Insight satellite. Georges Batroc and a team of twenty-five mercenaries were able to board the ship and subdue the crew. The crew were tied up in the galley under the guard of several men. Batroc and Ferdinand Lopez headed to the bridge and contacted S.H.I.E.L.D. Batroc demanded one and a half billion dollars in exchange for the release of the hostages.
Meanwhile, after being briefed by Brock Rumlow on the Quinjet, Captain America jumped without a parachute from the Quinjet into the ocean. Rising from the water, Rogers used stealth to silently subdue each mercenary he encountered. However, one was aimed to shoot Rogers in the back, but he was saved by the timely arrival of Rumlow, who had just parachuted down. Rumlow rescued Sitwell and the other hostages while Rogers started searching the ship for Batroc.
Black Widow, upon landing, began her own mission. Though Rogers was relying on her to secure the engine room of the ship, she used the mission as opportunity to copy on a USB drive information pertaining to Project Insight. Sitwell was on the ship to protect Project Insight's involvement. Rogers noticed that Romanoff was not committed to the mission, when she explained that his mission was not her mission.
Batroc and Rogers fought briefly, ending in the control room. Batroc abandoned ship and attempted to blow Romanoff and Rogers up, but they managed to escape.
Georges Batroc was captured by S.H.I.E.L.D. at a safe house in Algiers, Algeria, and subsequently interrogated. Captain America was displeased with Black Widow's performance on the mission and confronted Nick Fury about it. This lead Fury to show him the three Helicarriers under the Triskelion and for Fury to give Rogers an overview of what Project Insight was and its goals. After his conversation with Captain America and being unable to access the data on the USB drive, Fury decided to see Alexander Pierce about postponing the project.
After Fury realized that his access into the Project Insight's files were restricted, he confronted Alexander Pierce about it. Pierce promised to look into it and delay Project Insight; however, he contacted HYDRA agents and had the Winter Soldier tasked with assassinating Fury. After Fury's supposed death, Pierce alerted Captain America that Fury had hired Batroc to steal the intelligence aboard the Lemurian Star. Pierce asked Rogers about Fury's presence in his apartment, to which Rogers responded that Fury told him not to trust anybody. Pierce then proceeded to send the STRIKE team to eliminate Rogers.