- "Help us. Please, please, please."
- ―Hayley to Punisher
Captured by Billy Russo
Hayley and Carl were closing a stand and were prepared to engage in romantic affairs when they were approached by Billy Russo behind the corner. They were beaten and bloodied before they were gagged and roped to the horses on the carousel. During the duel between Russo and Castle, she and Carl cried and were, soon, threatened to beg for Castle's rescue. Eventually, the couple were freed and awaited the arrival of police. Carl and Hayley were questioned about the incident by Brett Mahoney and they told him about Castle.
- Pritchard - Employer
- Carl - Boyfriend and Co-Worker
- Frank Castle/Punisher - Savior
- Dinah Madani
- Brett Mahoney
- Billy Russo † - Kidnapper