Isabelle Hartley grabbed the Obelisk intending to stop Carl Creel from taking it, but she was unable to remove it from her grasp. Lance Hunter and Idaho attempted to rush her to a medical center via S.H.I.E.L.D. SUV as it slowly killed her. Not wanting to have the Obelisk inflict further harm on her, Hartley ordered Hunter to cut her arm off.
Before being able to do so, Idaho saw Carl Creel, transforming into concrete, walk into the middle of the road. This caused the vehicle to strike him and flip, killing Hartley and Idaho. Hunter survived the crash and pretended to have died, as Creel, having sustained no injuries, took the Obelisk and left. Hunter confirmed the deaths of Idaho and Hartley after they were both unresponsive.
Melinda May started to pursue Carl Creel, as Lance Hunter briefed her on the situation, but was ordered by Phil Coulson to not attack him, and pursue him. May tracked Creel at a diner, where he inadvertently caused the death of a waitress.
Raina contacted Coulson, and informed him about Creel, given that she wanted to obtain the Obelisk for herself instead of letting HYDRA take it. Raina had offered Creel a ring the night before that had been implanted with a tracking device.
Creel met Sunil Bakshi at a local park in Washington, D.C., where Hunter, the sole survivor of the prior car accident, attacked Creel using a high caliber sniper rifle, to no avail. As Creel tried to kill Hunter, Coulson neutralized the threat of Creel using the Overkill Device. His body was given to General Glenn Talbot as a gesture of good intentions from S.H.I.E.L.D.
- "I felt bad for kidnapping you, so I brought you a peace offering. Carl Creel."
"I thought Creel was dead."
"He's turned to stone, but he could always do that, so I'm not sure how long it'll hold. I've got him in a Cryostasis Chamber in the back of the van for... 58 more minutes before the juice runs out. I'd get him someplace secure pretty quick. Maybe a little more secure than last time. Just saying."
- ―Phil Coulson and Glenn Talbot[src]
The remains of the petrified waitress were taken by HYDRA and studied. Samples were used to create a concoction that duplicated the effects of the Obelisk; this concoction was tested at a Naval wedding party, and later used as a weapon to kill the Baroness, one of HYDRA's own leaders.
- Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: 2.01: Shadows
- Brett Dalton says Grant Ward it's been in the cell for 6 months
- Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: 2.02: Heavy is the Head
- Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: 2.05: A Hen in the Wolf House
- Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: 2.11: Aftershocks
- Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: 2.03: Making Friends and Influencing People