- "I know about Konchevsky, and I know about Poloznev and the teenagers in Chicago. I know all about that."
"That's right. So think what we'll do to you if you do not let our only child go. You will die slowly. I will kill everyone who so much as crossed paths with you, Mr. Castle."
- ―Frank Castle and Anderson Schultz
Having David Schultz being held hostage at a trailer, Frank Castle contacted Anderson and Eliza Schultz. Recording their dialogue, Castle stated that he knows everything about their assassinations and demanded to return Amy Bendix to him or David will die. While Anderson threatens to kill Castle and everyone he ever cared about, Eliza then snatched the phone away from him and promised that Castle was out of his depth if he wanted to challenge them, leading simply demand his request. Eliza called John Pilgrim for one last mission, informing him that David was taken by Castle and needed to be saved.
After his previous encounter with Pilgrim who took Bendix hostage, Castle returned to the trailer to find it empty, unbeknownst of him that Curtis Hoyle decided to let David go. Castle was called by Pilgrim who needed to take David to the Schultzes, having Castle to tell him that he's ready to return be reclaimed. As she was kept inside Pilgrim's stolen vehicle, Bendix noted that the Schultzes are just using Pilgrim to kill other people.
Pilgrim and Bendix arrived at the trailer where Castle claimed that David was with him and demanded to let Bendix go. Bendix escaped from Pilgrim's grasp and drove away from the place, Castle confessed to him that David was gone and that he doesn't know where he is. Castle and Pilgrim then had a brutal fight, leading Castle to be on a brink of defeating him. Before his death, Pilgrim begged Castle to spare his children after he kills Schultzes. After Castle realized that Pilgrim had children, he decided to spare him. In exchange, Pilgrim informed Castle about Schultzes' current location. While Castle and Bendix went to them, Pilgrim secretly took Michael and Lemuel outside of the mansion.
Meeting at the diner of their mansion, Eliza and Anderson Schultz discussed their current situation with their son and John Pilgrim. Despite of Eliza's objections upon him being killed, Anderson insisted that Pilgrim did all that they asked of him. Before Eliza could argue with her husband even further, Amy Bendix arrived into the dining room, holding her handgun in defense. While Bendix threatened them for killing her friends, Eliza thought about killing her with a knife before Anderson insisted on pulling the gun away from his wife.
Pointing at the gun closely to Eliza's head, Bendix asked her how it feels, noting that they killed all of her friends. Anderson then lost his temper and stood up to confront Bendix, leading her to point the gun at Anderson, while Eliza reached for the knife and attack Bendix. However, Eliza was suddenly shot in the head by the Punisher, much to Anderson's horror. While Anderson saw at his wife's dead body, Castle informed him that he did not intend to kill anyone but his wife sure made her choice.
Castle then showed him the recording of their conversation, which exposed all of Schultzes' crimes and Anderson's personal threats. Bendix told Anderson that she will bring the video recording to the New York Bulletin. Castle told Anderson that his son was compassionate and moral and noted how much people die from his hands. Now with the situation being settled, Castle gave Anderson a choice to make all of this right, handing him his gun and a bullet to commit suicide or live with the consequence. Once Castle and Bendix had both left his mansion, Anderson chose to put the gun in his mouth and commit suicide.
Without Eliza and Anderson Schultz or John Pilgrim trying to let get them killed, Frank Castle decided to let Amy Bendix go on on her own. Taken her to the bus station, Castle sat next to her on a bench and proceeded to talk to Bendix. Remembering some of their previous affairs, Castle expressed saying that he cared about her. Before Bendix could travel to Florida, Castle gave her contact of Curtis Hoyle's friend who owned a diving school. After given some money for the road, Castle noticed the bus that arrived and told Bendix to get on before she misses it. Before she could get on, Castle told Bendix to make sure to experience anything that could change her life only to be interrupted with a hug. Once she was boarded by the bus, Bendix took a moment to glance at Castle only to find him gone and left the station.