Can someone just clarify with me if I’ve got this right...
Steve Rogers makes an alternate timeline when he goes back in Endgame and lives his life out with Peggy. However, assuming he returns to the current timeline the year he left (2023) or at least past Peggy’s death, this would mean there was potentially two Captain America’s in that particular timeline.
Assuming everything plays out exactly the same, the 1945 Steve would still be found in 2012. They didn’t come across him because they were looking for him, they were looking for Hulk.
If Banner’s storyline plays out the same (we have no reason to assume it doesn’t) then the 1945 Steve Rogers would be found.