Thread:Marvelous 345678/@comment-27496405-20180723185324/@comment-3095612-20181124022614

BEJT wrote: I would go with Captain Marvel Prelude scene then Infinity War Prelude scene due to the natural order and the fact that they leave Syria after the Infinity War Prelude. Hmm, I should more closely reread the Syria scenes. I was coming from the thought that Infinity War Prelude was first. They took down the terrorists, the dirty bomb was there, they thought it was mission successful prematurely and were already thinking of disposal then moving onto the next op in Lebanon. Then in the Captain Marvel Prelude, more terrorists arrive at the building more quickly than they thought and start opening fire because they got tipped off somehow. So Falcon provides cover and they run the bomb to the Quinjet where Fury was waiting.

BEJT wrote: Yeah Coulson mentions that the Playground was founded during the beginning of S.H.I.E.L.D. in 1949 in I think Meet the New Boss, and there's some other details like Peggy's S.H.I.E.L.D. file that suggest 1949. I still have to rewatch it, lol. Okay, so you guys take the file as canon. Noted. That was the one in Avengers 1 promo material, right? Or am I thinking of something else?

BEJT wrote: I can't remember where it's said, it might have been Winter Soldier, but the SSR was integrated into S.H.I.E.L.D., becoming its science division. It still existed, but as a subsidiary of S.H.I.E.L.D.. Interesting.

BEJT wrote: Yeah I found out about that extended version recently. This isn't to do with the date S.H.I.E.L.D. was formed but just a comment - I wouldn't consider it hard canon, it's the same level as the deleted scenes where they're not technically canon but can give guidance for things because they're all-but. Because the extended version is essentially a deleted scene, as it canon exist as it is within the MCU, because it's in HD but filmed in 1953. The video is raw footage for the film and not an in-universe video because it hasn't been edited by Marvel to be in-universe-compatible. That's why I don't include it on my official canon list. True, but I liked that it gave a year to that Stalingrad anecdote, 1945 - so probably that January before they lose Bucky on the train and capture Zola.

BEJT wrote: If they started putting this together in Summer 2017, after Homecoming, and essentially copied our timeline... This is what it would look like (assuming the Stark deaths date is just a typo on their part forgetting to put "1991" so the point accidentally still falls under the "1987" heading). And then as Thor: Ragnarok, Black Panther, and Avengers: Infinity War came out, they just guessed them and added them where they guessed to their timeline (only getting 1 out of 3 correct).

I genuinely think this is what happened. Nowhere else is there a source on that Gamora date or that Black Widow date. It can't be coincidence. If they didn't copy our timeline, they copied someone else who copied our timeline. Yeah, sounds about right, someone on their team drylabs info without reaching out to one of you guys. But so messed up if your hunch is true. Hopefully they don't credit or cite the wiki in this book...