Thread:BEJT/@comment-32002564-20171124182046/@comment-26838855-20171124184417

123BC wrote: Dear BEJT, I would just like to apologize for the few times when I added Frank's birth year as 1982 on Punisher page, the only reason I added that was because I noticed that in the trivia section, that it said his birth year was 1982, also, I'm not the one who added that to the trivia just to be clear. Also I was wondering how we know that Frank's birthday is in November, I'm watching the show currently, and we know that Frank was born on the 15th, as David revealed this in episode 3, but according to the references, it says that the fact that he was born in November was revealed in episode 4, but I watched that already, but I didn't notice that anywhere, anyway please let me know how we know that Frank was born in November. Thanks.

signed, 123BC Don't worry about it. I wasn't being angry, sorry if it came off like that. For a long time now another user, I can't remember whom, has put that Frank signed up after 9/11 and thus put Frank's year of birth according to that. As far as I'm aware, having made extensive timeline notes through two watches of Daredevil - and with no citations ever provided - there is nothing ever saying that that is the case. I only just noticed the piece of trivia that that user must have added, which I never noticed to remove, which is why you thought that was the case - so it wasn't you who added it before, it's just you understandably following a previous user's erroneous work.

Unless someone finds a source for it, I am fairly certain there is no mention of him signing up after 9/11, and therefore no year of birth.

As for the November thing, in Episode 3, Micro says that it is now the 15th (in the early hours) of the month - Frank's birthday. We don't know which month though. About 36 hours later, though, in daytime of the 16th of whichever month, Curtis visits Lewis in his foxhole. This is in Episode 4. He then asks Lewis why he's hiding in a foxhole "in November". Therefore, the month is November, and Frank's birthday is November 15th. I was not the user who added that, I just added the citations, but it's correct - just not the year.