Thread:Marvelous 345678/@comment-24669364-20170327194916/@comment-26838855-20170411155019

Marvelous 345678 wrote: All right then, I am not wrong it comes from the Official Box of Phase 1 and Avengers Blu Ray and other details. They are not fake if it was in that way one of the admins would have deleted it Not necessarily to be honest. There are a few 100% fan-made ones on there, and the dates are given the source of that image, which looks convincing enough until further inspection. They look like they're from the Phase One box set, but they're not, I've researched heavily into the contents of that set, it's just this:



This:



This:



And a very similar version of this, this one is a mockup of the one in the box:



And that's it.

Now I did some more digging, and aside from all the evidence I listed above: BEJT wrote: So I checked, and every single one of these dates is the actor's actual birthday. Romanoff and Barton are exactly the same date as Johansson and Renner respectively, Coulson and Fury being exactly 3 years after Gregg and Jackson's respective dates of birth, and Hill being exactly 2 years earlier than Smulders.

It seems highly coincidental for all these characters to have the same birthday as their actors, especially with Coulson's DoB firmly set on July 8, 1964, with his badge in Avengers and AoS Pilot, as well as a BTS image from Iron Man. Also, this suggests that Coulson's parents died exactly 5 years apart to the day. Another massive coincidence.

I also looked carefully, and the official files for Barton, the Tesseract, and Item 47 all have the Marvel copyright at the bottom. These do not.

They also have images taken directly from the films/one-shots. Now Marvel isn't prone to using direct footage as in-universe footage - some of Ross' presentation in Civil War, Peter watching footage in class, The Wing Way promo, and the official files from the Phase One boxset - but it does seem odd.

Plus last known address: S.H.I.E.L.D. Helicarrier, and previous address: Mobile... really? And an exact second of death for Coulson?


 * BTS images from Iron Man and The Avengers have Coulson's badge with 1964JUL08. His badge shown in The Avengers and clearly in Pilot is 1964JUL08. His birthday is July 8, 1964, yet this file decided he has Clark Gregg's birthday, on April 2, 1965
 * In Pilot, it is clearly shown on Maria Hill's badge that her date of birth is 1982APR04, yet this file decided she has Cobie Smulders' birthday, on April 3, 1980
 * The Marvel Database lists Coulson's birthday, using the source of Pilot, and gives no other source. It lists Hill's birthday, using the source of Pilot, and gives no other source. It lists Romanoff's birthday as simply "1984", based purely on the source of Captain America: The Winter Soldier, and gives not other source. It has no date of birth listed for Fury or Barton.

It's gotta be unofficial, no?!