Thread:Marvelus/@comment-26838855-20190116120806/@comment-26838855-20190208025032

Marvelus wrote: I have been reading your notes for Punisher S2 and while you point out that May is the most likely, some of your notes seem to imply that we are on Early 2018. You placing the flashback from Jigsaw and the doctor on July 2017, 6 months after he woke up. But she said during May 2018 that she worked with him for months, so I don't know which is your outcome. But I will wait for it. Yeah, that scene is July 2017, 6 months after he woke up. Works well enough as "months" before May 2018.

The notes just examine each piece of evidence, and the evidence about the time since Season 1 would place the season in early 2018 rather than May. But overall, the notes conclude/will conclude that it's May and that that works best.

When I write the notes, I write them from the perspective of someone watching for the first time and after each scene writing notes for that scene. It means that it clearly presents the thought process for anyone reading, instead of seemingly randomly coming to a conclusion based on information that hasn't yet been presented. So the earlier episodes' notes suggest early 2018 because that's what one might assume as they are watching the season until Episode 7, when it becomes clear that it's May 2018. So 6.8/9 of the episodes I've written up are, I guess, from the perspective of someone thinking it's early 2018, which might be why you've got that impression.

It's May 2018. Just like Jessica Jones: Season 2, Luke Cage: Season 2, Iron Fist: Season 2, and Daredevil: Season 3, there are lines implying that in the writers' minds, it's been a bit less time than it actually has to be if you analyse the evidence, but the lines have leeway, and thus we just have to perform slight stretches and then it works. Same as always, we have to make a few stretches based on some slight assumptions, but otherwise, it works fine.

Marvelus wrote: And about the stadium, didn't think it of that way. That is very sad. Enjoying a game and the puff. But if we end up using June, June 21st sounds about right. Well the ones in small/grey are barely worth mentioning because you still have to assume there's a difference in the MCU to the real world because the timing has to be different. So it still doesn't match the real world, it's just I guess slightly closer to the real world if you're only shifting from the real world by hours rather than like a day. And June 21st is one of those, it doesn't really work anyway despite being a Thursday because it's the wrong time.

But anyway, the June option is Wednesday, June 27th-Thursday, June 28th, not 20th-21st, because Scott's sentence would end on June 20, 2018 following his arrest on June 24, 2016 minus a few days for prison days counting for double, we know it's a Wednesday (unless we have to push it to a Thursday but that was only in the case of taking the 4/30 date, and even then only one potential option). Thus Infinity War would be 27th-28th when taking the June option that came about due to the Ant-Man and the Wasp 2-year sentence (it also can't be later than June 27th-28th because that is literally the last days of the school term for Peter, unless the MoMA trip is during summer vacation which seems very unlikely, especially since Feige said after Endgame peter returns to junior year).

But as I said, I wasn't listing those dates because they're the only options or anything. Just pointing out another minor piece of evidence we now have, and doing the research to accompany it. The fact that it's during the 2018 MLB season, which it is no matter where it falls in the 3-month range of options, is the more important part.