Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-27464043-20151230192612/@comment-14267015-20160222232449

ASGARDIANBRONY wrote: FortressMaximus93 wrote: Nothing points to the Soul Stone being on Asgard, you're only giving us a coincidence as proof. I could say Dr. Strange will have the Time and Soul Stones because the Eye of Agamotto has a green gem in it and Strange's magic is orange in a picture and no one could really argue because there's nothing to show I'm wrong. We have to base our information on what has been given to us thus far; Volstagg said the Tesseract is the only Stone on Asgard, that is the truth until we find out otherwise. If you turn out to be right congratulations, if not oh well. he said it would be unwise to have two stones on Asgard, he did not specifically say only one stone was on Asgard. I did not give one coincidence, I gave many "coincidences", and when there are many "coincidences" they should be looked at as evidence. Odin has soul manipulation powers, mjolnir reads souls, Asgards energy is orange, heimdalls eyes are orange, heimdall has stated seeing souls, Thors vision points to a stone in Ragnarok, Valhalla would be a perfect fit for the soul gems soul dimension, these are facts. It is more likely than not that the soul stone will be in THOR: RAGNAROK. I agree that the Soul Stone will most likely appear in Thor Ragnarok, I don't see anywhere else it could turn up since James Gunn said there wouldn't be a Stone in GotG 2. However, the cinematic universe and the comic universe work very differently. Valhalla may be completely different in the MCU which would put a serious dent in your theory, it's only ever been mentioned once after all. And Odin has never been shown manipulating souls, if he had it would be shown under his powers on his wiki page. If you're referring to how he depowered Thor, I'd imagine that had more to do with changing his biology than his soul. Heimdall "seeing souls" was likely more of a metaphor, if he could see someone's soul I doubt Loki and the Dark Elves would have ever been able to sneak up on or past him. I'd also like to point out that in Dark World, he could tell something was there but not what. Finally, as for the appearance of Asgardian magic, it seems all magic is orange. We have a picture of Dr. Strange casting some form of orange energy. This could mean that all magic is connected to the Soul Stone, or the people working on the movie saw that magic in Thor was orange and decided to keep it that way. We just don't have enough information on the Soul Stone to make any sort of call on what or where it is. This is just like when people assumed the Stone in the Scepter was green because of one scene in Avengers, and then there was some debate about whether it was the Mind or Soul Stone.