Thread:CirUmeUela/@comment-27496405-20180307074410/@comment-26838855-20180624021824

David Kaique wrote: Thank you! I do remember that shot now. Funnily enough, that was the one moment when I was watching where I went "There could be a date there, but I can't be bothered to pause right now, I'll check it on my rewatch." Naturally, of course, it was the one shot with a date😂. The article says, "Currently chairs a committee in 2017," so yeah, that suggests it's 2017.

Marvelous 345678 wrote: It is a fictional universe, that episode of Game of Thrones could have got realeased on late 2016. Maybe, Jon Snow never really died xD. Also, it appears to be definitely 2016. Misty Knight may have recovered completely in a lapse of 4 months (like you said because of Yo-yo situation) and then her recpvery therapy (which we can see it's recently beggining) may take a month later. So October 2016 fits much much better than you may think. And we have always known that for the Netflix placement we need to wait for two shows at least to define where is it exactly into our timeline, and after Defenders it was clear that it was going to happen something like that and it is good for me actually. I know that if necessary, sure, Game of Thrones can be assumed to be ahead of the real world - or the guy on the street is just saying "bend the knee" with regards to Daenerys in 2016 as just a general phrase she might use, and it happened to to later, in 2017, become an actual recurring quote of hers from the show.

Apparently as well as the magazine, I'm hearing there's a moment in Episode 6 where Mariah's bank account says her next statement will be September 2018, suggesting it's currently August 2018. But that's the sort of thing that, like the magazine, doesn't necessarily need to be hard fact. The year is very blurry in the magazine, and I'm assuming the bank statement date isn't particularly clear (if it is, that's a bit more difficult), and the statement doesn't 100% give us a date, but rather implies a date. Also, apparently in Episode 4 Misty has a 9/18 registration sticker, meaning it is most likely between September 2017 and September 2018 (1-year registration), if not at least between September 2016 and September 2018 (2-year registration), and Shades has a 1/18 registration sticker, so likely between January 2017 and January 2018 (1-year), if not at least between January 2016 and January 2018 (2-year).

I just find this frustrating. Both Cloak & Dagger and Luke Cage are causing problems again.

Marvelous 345678 wrote: I wouldn't worry about other Timelines falling around. It was going to be a surprise but... As you may know my mother language is Spanish. I contacted a spanish blog called Blog de Superheroes and periodically I published several articles regarding the MCU Timeline regarding this website. You can search it on Google like this "Cronología del Universo cinematográfico de Marvel BdS". In the comments I have explained every detail and how WE work here on the wikia, if I am not wrong I even mentioned you BEJT as the main piece for our little puzzle. However, they really LOVED our job and thanked me and us for all the work we have put into. They prefer our timeline placement of the shows and they want to watch the MCU again as we suggest it becuase it is mostly perfect and accurate. Awesome! I had a quick look but unfortunately can't scroll through all of it now. Still in the midst of exams, one more to go, and got to push through to Monday - don't have time for anything else yet, have to work hard knowing that I'll have loads of time soon. So yeah, sorry, don't have much time right now, but the quick look I had was good work!

Marvelous 345678 wrote: Which is the surprise? The (users) have asked for a book in PDF version of our timeline and I was planning to do it for the next year after Phase Three is over and Marvel Official Timeline is released. I was also planning to do the book in Spanish and English version in order to reach Comicbook.com website and other pages so to make our timeline trending topic. Why did I want to publish articles? I was bored and there was no show or movie by the time so I contacted the admin of the blog and presented to him the idea. He loved it. I am currently on August 2014. In two weeks the placement for Jessica Jones will be in there. I may have missed a few details for the references as the articles requires a minimun of 1200 words and there is plenty information to put on. The admin wants to publish the book and I will in the Introduction put this Wikia as main reference as we work here. Also I did it because I wanted to show our work to the rest of the fandom and make you (BEJT) realize that your efforts to build this amazing timeline is beyond amazing, it IS perfect.

So yeah. That is what I am going to do. "It is time to make things right". Don't you think? That's fantastic! Wow!

I have a few questions to ask:
 * 1) So you're planning on getting this PDF out around April/May 2019?
 * 2) When you say "the admin wants to publish the book", do you mean publish online as a PDF or publish hardcopy? Hardcopy would probably be quite difficult legally and money-wise and with all sorts of things - it would probably not be a good idea. But a PDF would be really cool.
 * 3) When you say "minimun of 1200 words" do you mean maximum 1200 words? Minimum is the smallest number required, maximum is the limit. So are you saying that you had to cut things down because there is a word limit of 1200 words on the articles?
 * 4) I'm surprised you thought there was a dead period for content, it's felt pretty constant to me for the last year or so😂. But we'll have a pretty calm period coming up. Between early August 2018 (when Cloak & Dagger finishes and Ant-Man and the Wasp comes out here) and March 2019 (Captain Marvel), for 7 months, we'll have no films, and only a few shows - Daredevil: Season 3, Runaways: Season 2, Iron Fist: Season 2, and possibly New Warriors: Season 1. This should help with catching up as well - but my 3 months of no commitments, which is right around the corner, will also help. I'm going to be doing a lot on here for the next 3 months.
 * 5) How's the book going to work? Is it verbatim copying of the wiki pages? Is it each point, but cut down? Is it copies of your articles, which are cut down versions? Does it omit smaller, less important details? I'm interested.
 * 6) Thank you for doing this, and the introduction, and for giving me recognition, and your compliments. That makes me proud of my work, and you should be proud too!
 * 7) This summer, one of the things I will be doing, as I comb through and do my major project, is cleaning up every timeline page to be perfected and referenced and all under control. There could well be several small corrections, but I don't want to make your work retroactively incorrect. Is it possible to go back and make minor edits to your posted articles, to make some slight corrections if anything comes up, if you want to? And hopefully, if you're intending on finishing the PDF/book next year, then that won't cause problems for that, because the pages should be all cleaned up over the next few months.
 * 8) Is there any way in which I can help with this project? I'd be happy to, however I can with the time that I have.

Marvelous 345678 wrote: Cloak and Dagger seems to be 2016-2017 overall. It would be crazy to have it on 2015. Exactly my thinking... 2015 is just weird. But also, I don't really know what to do. Its is a mess. The accident is pretty firmly April 18, 2007, because that security footage was so blatantly shown. Nathan's ID contradicts this (but also even misspells his surname...), and the 6/6/08 vision somewhat contradicts it (though that can be easily explained away).

Then we have the dialogue, which is clearly placing it 8 years on. So February 2015.

Tyrone was 8 at the time of the accident, so he was born between April 19, 1998 and April 18, 1999. Contradicts the date from his mother's vision, but that can be easily explained.

If he were born October 1, 1998-April 18, 1999 he'd be a sophomore in February 2015, and be 15-16. I doubt he's a sophomore with the line about 3 years, and just how old he and his classmates look and act. If he were born April 19, 1998-September 30, 1998 he'd be a junior in February 2015 and he'd be 16. Possible.

If he were born October 1, 1998-April 18, 1999 he'd be a junior in February 2016, and be 16-17. If he were born April 19, 1998-September 30, 1998 he'd be a senior in February 2016 and he'd be 17.

If he were born October 1, 1998-April 18, 1999 he'd be a senior in February 2017, and be 17-18. If he were born April 19, 1998-September 30, 1998, it can't be later than February 2016 for him to still be in school.

Then we have the in-universe music, released up to April 2017, suggesting February 2018. But OK, different universe, the music doesn't matter all too much. The phones used and software seem more 2017, but I'm not entirely sure, and again, different universe, maybe the Apple devices and software are a bit further ahead.

Then we have the article from the latest episode that David Kaique pointed out. "Currently chairs a committee in 2017."

If the accident had been more like 2009, this would be far easier, but it's so clearly 2007. Agh, how hard is it to map it out before they make props/write timeline dialogue?