Thread:Marvelus/@comment-27496405-20190519011243/@comment-26838855-20190614192939

Nox23's Videos (Nox23)
Nox23 wrote: The last couple days at work Ive had on my interwoven videos of Cloak and Dagger, Iron Fist and Daredevil and it's real fun. Some of the depressing/energetic music from Cloak and Dagger works real well fading into scenes of Daredevil which is a nice treat. Thanks for all the help interpreting it all, you guys are rockstars Thank you, and sorry that we couldn't yet provide the exact order of scenes for you. There's a backlog of work on the timeline to be done. Getting through it.

Jessica Jones: Season 3 (Edward Zachary Sunrose, Assassin1and2, Rman823, Marvelus, ProBot1227)
Edward Zachary Sunrose wrote: No spoilers, but the costume shop is just that, it obviously advertises Halloween costumes, but under the name it just says "New York Costume Shop", which tells me it's open year round.

Also, there's a fair amount of people wearing windbreakers and light jackets, so maybe it's still early 2018? I remember the cold weather (in Massachusetts, at least) went well into late May last year. (This year, it's still cold today in mid-June.) Thank you! I've only watched Episode 1 so far.

At the end of Episode 1 it says it's "18°" at "8:46PM". I'm assuming Fahrenheit, but that's very cod - it's lower than the average daily low for any month of the year in New York.

I know at least some of some o fit was filmed during a very hot time, Krysten Ritter talked about it in the featurette about her directing.

Assassin1and2 wrote: There is a game playing in episode 1 I am not good with American sports so if anyone can tell what the clubs are maybe we can have a date of the game. Yeah I spent a long time researching to try and find out who the teams are, but I can't. "RPC" vs. "BU" - the only thing I could find was Boston University but it would also seem that they don't play American football anymore.

Rman823 wrote: I'm a couple episodes in, and there's also a pumpkin sticker when Jessica meets the guy at the bar. It's in the background, so hopefully it can be ignored or assumed that it's just been leftover. But other than that I think it could easily be Spring/Summer 2018. EDIT: I completely forgot about the Football game which would place the season in the Fall. I didn't notice that, will have to look out for it on rewatch.

Spring 2018 would be ideal. If necessary and possible it can be late 2017, which annoyingly breaks the Netflix chronological order but is better than it being post-Snap.

Does anyone who's watched a few episodes know if there is a line in the ones they've watched about it being a year since Season 2?

Marvelus wrote: Season began filming on June 2018. So we can place it for sure around May-June 2018. Doesn't seem like Halloween for me. Late June to December. Krysten did Episode 2 which would've been around July, so that makes sense for why she talked about how hot it was.

If it places itself when it filmed it would be around September 2018. Let's hope not.

Rman823 wrote: Football Season in America begins in September and we can see a game on TV. I noticed a Julia Roberts People magazine cover in the background of a newsstand and found that it was from May 2017. So, it didn't help. It's annoying that American football season is so limited over just a few months. I was thinking "OK well this basically just rules out like summer I'm assuming, which was the least likely time it would be taking place anyway", but looked it up and found out American football season is only like September-December?

It's not the be all and end all. There's the Running of the Bulls thing in All the Comforts of Home that just ultimately gets discarded. It's easier to assume the game is at a weird time of the year or it's maybe just highlights from a game than to assume the Snap has happened (unless this is 2017).

Thanks for checking that magazine. I stopped and analysed all the computers in the episode but the only thing was Jeri having folders on her desktop for 2016 cases and 2017 cases, essentially meaning this is no earlier than 2017 - which we already knew.

Marvelus wrote: What makes you belive it is a recent game? They can still show an old game. It's not likely, especially since this doesn't appear to be popular teams. But it might be highlights from last season or something.

Rman823 wrote: Chances are they meant for the game to be live. I don't see why a bar would have an old game on sometime in the Spring. Definitely meant to be live, but likely not done with care.

Marvelus wrote: Yeah. I doubt it... Assassin1and2 wrote: Why I have never seen a bar play a months or a year old game. It is ALWAYS live. Marvelus wrote: I have seen otherwise xD. And that does not mean anything anyway. It is the MCU, different Universe to us. Well it does mean something. Just it's not the end of the world.

ProBot1227 wrote: Yeah, but it still reflects real life to a point. The days of the week are the same, months are the same, years, wars, etc. It can be assumed that it came out when it did until it can't, in my opinion. Marvelus wrote: Yeah. The days of the week are not the same. It is the leniency we take to place the things in the timeline. Everything so far points out to Mid 2018. The days of the week are the same. There's sufficient evidence that they're the same, and the times they're not are just mistakes.

Nothing so far has actually pointed to mid-2018, that's just the hope.

ProBot1227 wrote: Meh, I think that that's just a mistake. A canonical mistake timeline-wise, but I don't think there's a rule making it so that any item in the Marvel Cinematic Universe has to follow an incorrect system of days, if you get what I mean. As I said, until it can't.

Correct me if I'm wrong, though. I think I'm following what you're saying - if you're asking if there's some consistent offset to the dates, there isn't. This discussion has been had a few times over the years, there's much more evidence for the dates being the same than there is for them being -3, -2, -1, +1, +2, or +3.

Marvelus wrote: We take leniency in here to lie everything down. That is my knowledge so far. What do you mean?

ProBot1227 wrote: Fair enough. Rman823 wrote: There are examples where the days match and times they don't. For example, the June calendar in Captain Marvel is accurate. Yeah, and there's not only more evidence for matching than not, but if you look at it as the seven options and not just "match or not match": There's way, way more evidence for 0 than any other option.
 * Thursdays in the real world are Mondays in the MCU (-3)
 * Thursdays in the real world are Tuesdays in the MCU (-2)
 * Thursdays in the real world are Wednesdays in the MCU (-1)
 * Thursdays in the real world are Thursdays in the MCU (0)
 * Thursdays in the real world are Fridays in the MCU (+1)
 * Thursdays in the real world are Saturdays in the MCU (+2)
 * Thursdays in the real world are Sundays in the MCU (+3)

Marvelus wrote: Some days match. Some days do not match which indicates the days of the months in the MCU change from year to year... So yes" leniency. No no the ones that are off are just wrong. This has been discussed before, considering all the calendars we've seen, the MCU doesn't have any sort of weird extra days or anything, it's just the same dates as the real world and occasionally there's a prop mistake.

ProBot1227 wrote: Over on the comic board, Lebnyx found out that at 38 minutes in, the Empire State Building is green. Selfishmisery pointed out that this could be in reference to Earth Day 2018, which was on 22nd April 2018. https://www.thecomicboard.com/threads/marvel-cinematic-universe-timeline-continued.14631/page-58 I don't look at The Comic Board anymore because I don't have time to catch up yet and I get frustrated when I'm reading a conversation and can't reply to it. But thank you, I do try to look up when there's a significant Empire State Building colour, though it looked just like the normal standard white colour to me.

Marvelus wrote: That is great!!! Thank you so much ProBot1227.

Rman823 wrote: 3 episodes in and if you ignore the Football game at the bar, I think the season could easily be Spring/Summer 2018. Not entirely sure when exactly filming began (I know it was some point in June) but the ESB was also lit green June 15th which could have been when it was filmed. Another possibility is August 15th. Yeah late June. The Empire State Building often doesn't match, it's not too important, but also it looked white to me.

Nox23 wrote: Just got a line "Mothers day is six months away" which is probably the most specific a Netflix show has ever been regarding time. Also Trish has commented on having her powers at least a full year and Malcolm has plans to be working where he's working for "another year" which possibly implies he's passed the year mark. So it sounds like November 2018 which would explain a football game being on. Regardless I'm really enjoying the season so far, idk why the reviews have been sour, probably because it can't possibly live up to being the grand finale for all of Marvel Netflix. Yikes. Other than Daredevil doing Christmas and The Punisher doing "November"/Thanksgiving, yeah.

Well, November 2018 then. *Sigh*. At least it's slightly longer post-Snap than we were worried about but come on.

Glad to hear you're enjoying it because yeah, not seen the best reviews.

Marvelus wrote: Didn't Trish say something about being Spring in Episode 2? And that "Mother's Day" line is problematic. I am loving the Season as well @Nox23. ProBot1227 wrote: So post snap? SMH ;( *Throws hands in the air in exasperation.*

Rman823 wrote: So, once again it's "pre snap" even though it's post snap. From what we've seen, I think it's a little harder to pretend this is a post snap world like A.O.S. Especially if this is just mere months after it. And the lines about it being a year confirm that it can't be October-November 2017, ugh. But the football game and pumpkin sticker at the bar help support the Mother's Day line. Oh well. It's a ridiculous assumption that has to be made. For goodness' sake.