Thread:Marvelous 345678/@comment-27496405-20180723185324/@comment-26838855-20181214194218

Shabook wrote: I just now found out the following comments while making and despite it's a few months old, I can't help but replying as I can't stand some lies that were sprayed over there. Hey man I'm sorry if you think I've been spraying lies, you know I try to be honest and polite and kind. If ever I have said something wrong, it's a misunderstanding, not a lie. Shabook wrote: BEJT wrote: I've had plenty of discussions with Shabook about it, but to no avail. He's done a lot of great stuff and allowed a lot of things for our work, so no hard feelings or anything, but I really do disagree with his "real time until proven otherwise" policy.

For the upteenth time. It's not "my policy", it's what Marvel said back in the day. And until otherwise proven by official sources of the same quality, what Marvel, a director, producer or showrunner, or an otherwise important member of the crew says is set in stone for this wiki. That's one of this wiki's pillars. I don't know when I said that but I would hope I have improved the way I speak about Wiki policies since, as we've had discussions about making sure I don't accidentally pin something on you. As for a source, I would provide this, but I understand if it's not enough.

Shabook wrote: BEJT wrote: I really do disagree with [...] his feeling that the columns system doesn't suggest concurrence.

Again, not my "feeling". It's the way, for example, every newspaper in every country of the world throughout all history is written. And one column is not related in any way to the one just next to it. Not my fault if people doesn't want to understand that. If the wiki allowed flowcharts to be added that would be the way that page would be displayed, but since it's not possible, this is the lesser evil. Yeah we discussed this, it's fine. Also, I saw you improved the column system on the Timeline page anyway since then and really liked it!

Shabook wrote: BEJT wrote: There's one comment from Michele Fazekas from the time Season 1 was coming out where she said that they "sort of imagined" the one-shot as the end of the series, and Shabook decides this is confirmation that the one-shot is set after the whole show, and overrules all the evidence.

As stated above, I don't "decide" anything. A showrunner said something, and until otherwise proven by a source of the same rank, i.e.: A showrunner in an interview, or through an in-universe specific statement, this wiki takes it into account over whatever any fan claim. OK well I feel I did present evidence directly in the one-shot and shows as well as other comments from Markus and McFeely that counter-acted it but oh well.

Shabook wrote: BEJT wrote: The show could have gone on for years and I think it would still be placed there on the Timeline page. And yet, it didn't, so working with "What If"s is not this wikis purpose. Again sorry I don't remember when I said these things but I think all I was saying there was an extra point and not an actual piece of evidence, I agree, shouldn't work with "What if"s.

Shabook wrote: With all this said, the main Timeline will be open for editing for 24 hours. After that period of time, each and every edit will be reviewed and, if deemed necessary, undone. Oh, awesome. OK I'll try to change some plans and focus on that over the next 24 hours. Thank you for this opportunity. I assume it would be best to edit in small pieces rather than in bulk so pieces can be undone individually?

Thank you for your time, sorry for any miscommunication in the past. I hope I've improved in the way I discuss things relating to policy since then, from our discussions.